WHY MECHANICAL DISC BRAKES AREN’T WORTH IT

Tech Talk

I made the move to disc brakes but don’t want to bother with bleeding a hydraulic system and maintenance. What are my options, and what would it entail to switch to a mechanical disc caliper?

First and foremost, I want to be clear when I say that I think this is a bad idea and would be a definite downgrade. We have covered this more than a few times, but, in our opinion, mechanical disc brakes are probably worse than even rim brakes for the most part.

There are a few models that could compare in performance, but nothing in comparison to a modern hydraulic system. On top of that, the truth is, maintenance for the most part is minimal and easy.

If you are dead set on making the switch, I would warn that it will likely be expensive, as you will need new shifter/brake hoods that accommodate a cable. The bike will likely need to be partially disassembled, and I’d say most shops would hit you with at least $200 for labor, plus the cost of the calipers. It will without a doubt add weight, too, as the plastic hydraulic hose is extremely light, and the steel-lined housing and cables are heavy in comparison.

I’ll finish with, “Don’t do it.” Give the new system a chance and accept the evolution. Sure, it’s different but honestly, as we covered last month, it’s easy if you want to learn it.

MORE TECH TALK

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

Comments are closed.